The thermian argument
WebNo. (edit: the crticism of the thermian argument) is nott a fallacy. It is a highly specific argument to a highly specific context. Fallacies deal with general logic with rules that can … WebMay 29, 2024 · The Thermian Argument is a problem that comes up rather frequently when discussing the tropes of crafting a story. Named for the Thermians of Galaxy Quest who cannot comprehend the difference between fiction and true history, to make a Thermian Argument is to enter a discussion surrounding the choices made in creating a story and to …
The thermian argument
Did you know?
WebTwitter: http://twitter.com/FoldableHumanAsk.fm: http://ask.fm/FoldableHumanWritten and Performed by Dan Olson WebThe 'Thermian Argument' Is Absolute Sophistry (2024) Quotes. It looks like we don't have any Quotes for this title yet. Be the first to contribute! Just click the "Edit page" button at …
WebMar 14, 2024 · In that case what you are saying is that it comes down to what people like. That's not a very convincing argument either. I understand that the Thermian argument and that the deterministic nature of fiction are not the same but my point is that you can't try and separate what happens in-universe as independent of the author one moment and then try … WebThis is an example of the Thermian Argument. Their difference is a form of visual storytelling that doesn't make sense in- or out-of-universe. The Bad Batch could have all been brown skinned with different facial features commonly associated with Polynesians, making them look similar to regular clones, but not exactly like them.
WebJan 9, 2024 · This is, at its heart, what Olson dubbed the Thermian Argument after the eponymous aliens from the film Galaxy Quest, who treated all fiction as being absolutely real. And it’s a really, really bad argument on a lot of levels, starting with the fact that it treats creative decisions as if they’re the same as normal choices of verisimilitude. WebApr 9, 2024 · Kirin and Namgi have a mission to go on and run into Ryugi. Running into him unfortunately brings up some bad trauma, luckily we get some comfort. (This happens …
WebJul 22, 2024 · Huh, that's a Thermian argument right there. It's in-universe. But, at the same time, it also seems to hold explanatory power over why an author might have made the choices they did. The writer might be thinking, okay, "Goblins rape women to reproduce, so it makes sense that they would focus exclusively on female victims."
WebMar 13, 2024 · In a 2015 video, Folding Ideas host Dan Olson calls this “The Thermian Argument” where people defend objectionable content with in-universe reasoning. … karaoke more hearts than mineWebNov 12, 2024 · Dan Olson argues in his video from 2015 that it’s not permissible to defend “problematic” content in a piece of fiction on the basis of verisimilitude – that is, on the … karaoke mixer with digital key controlWebJan 28, 2024 · The Thermian Argument is used as a stupid method to shield a story decision from criticism by offering in-text explanations for choices in writing when it's obvious … karaoke microphone with stand near meWebJan 31, 2016 · The Thermian argument so themed by its creator Dan Olsen, is an invention to shut down people who use in context defenses to in his words “... karaoke mp3 downloads freeWebDec 12, 2015 · The Thermian Argument is a logical fallacy that occurs when a question or criticism concerning the political statements that can be gleaned from a game or other … karaoke monitor stand flat screenWebJul 22, 2024 · The Thermian Argument is a logical fallacy that occurs when a question or criticism concerning the political statements that can be gleaned from a game or other … karaoke microphone with songs includedWeb6. david-saint-hubbins • 4 mo. ago. The commentary for The Limey (1999), directed by Steven Soderbergh and written by Lem Dobbs, has some really interesting and funny moments, particularly when Dobbs complains about the fact that Soderbergh got praised for stuff that was simply in the script. 5. garysdrunk • 4 mo. ago. law of the barbary coast 1949